The 22 Best (and Worst) Grocery Stores in NYC, Ranked by Real Prices (2026)
We priced 20 staples at 368 stores across the five boroughs. ALDI, Food Bazaar and Key Food came out cheapest; Gristedes, D'Agostino and 7-Eleven most expensive.
What are the best grocery stores in NYC if price is what you care about? We priced 20 everyday staples at 368 stores across the five boroughs, covering 27 chains and 134,789 prices collected between October 6 and November 5, 2026. The cheapest grocer in the city was ALDI, at about 37% below the New York median. The cheapest full-service supermarkets were Food Bazaar and Key Food. The most expensive were Gristedes and D'Agostino, at roughly 54-58% above the median, with Citarella and 7-Eleven higher still.
The more useful finding is about Manhattan. When we compared the same product at the same chain, Manhattan prices were within a couple of percent of Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx and Staten Island at most chains, and identical at Trader Joe's. Manhattan groceries cost more mostly because of which stores are on the block, not because chains charge Manhattan more. That changes the strategy: switching stores matters far more than switching boroughs.
Below is the full ranking of 22 New York City grocery stores, the price table behind it, what each chain is actually good at, and the institutions (Key Food's cooperative, C-Town's independent owners, H Mart's Queens roots, Kalustyan's on Lexington) that make New York grocery shopping unlike anywhere else. For live prices at your own address, compare prices across NYC stores by ZIP.
The one-minute verdict
- Cheapest overall: ALDI (index 63). The catch is that it has few stores in the five boroughs; we had prices from only a handful.
- Cheapest full-service supermarkets: Food Bazaar (79) and Key Food (84). They beat the median by about 21% and 16%, and both have many stores in the outer boroughs.
- Best value big-box: Costco (89), Wegmans (90) and Target (91), if one is reachable.
- Pantry wins at "expensive" stores: Trader Joe's (96) has some of the cheapest butter, bread and pasta in the city. Whole Foods (120) has cheap 365-brand peanut butter and pasta.
- Most expensive supermarkets: Gristedes (154) and D'Agostino (158), two Manhattan banners under the same ownership. Their prices are nearly identical item for item.
- Convenience tax: 7-Eleven (216) charged about twice the NYC median on the staples we could price. A gallon of milk was $7.59 against a $4.99 median.
- The Manhattan myth: same chain, same product, Manhattan vs the outer boroughs is usually within 2%. The store you pick matters far more than the borough you're in.
NYC grocery prices by store: the full ranking
This is the table to use. Index compares each chain's cheapest version of each staple with the NYC median for that staple, then averages across every staple we could price there. 100 is a typical NYC price; 80 means about 20% cheaper; 150 means about 50% more.
| Rank | Store | Price source | Index (100 = NYC median) | Staples priced (of 20) | Stores sampled | Milk, 1 gal | Eggs, dozen | Boneless chicken breast, per lb | Sandwich bread, 20 oz |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ALDI | Store site | 63 | 13 | 2 | $2.71† | $1.85† | $1.99† | $2.15† |
| 2 | Food Bazaar | Instacart | 79 | 16 | 15 | $4.99 | $2.79 | $1.85 | $3.11 |
| 3 | Key Food | Instacart | 84 | 19 | 3 | $3.29† | $1.58 | $2.24 | $3.16 |
| 4 | Dollar Tree | Instacart | 88 | 11 | 30 | $5.00 | — | — | $1.72 |
| 5 | Costco | Instacart | 89 | 12 | 5 | $4.71 | $2.34 | $5.21 | $3.15† |
| 6 | Wegmans | Instacart | 90 | 19 | 2 | $3.29 | $2.43 | $2.69 | $1.63 |
| 7 | Target | Instacart | 91 | 17 | 7 | $4.99 | $1.99 | $3.75† | $3.83 |
| 8 | The Fresh Grocer | Instacart | 95 | 16 | 1 | — | $4.69† | — | $2.00† |
| 9 | Trader Joe's | Store site | 96 | 12 | 17 | — | $5.99 | — | $2.08 |
| 10 | ShopRite | Instacart | 96 | 17 | 8 | $4.98 | $3.96 | $3.60 | $2.31 |
| 11 | Western Beef | Instacart | 103 | 16 | 9 | $5.19 | $1.53 | $3.69† | — |
| 12 | Stop & Shop | Instacart | 106 | 18 | 13 | $5.09 | $2.39 | $3.49 | $4.95 |
| 13 | C-Town | Instacart | 107 | 16 | 10 | $5.49 | $2.19 | $8.79† | $3.74 |
| 14 | Morton Williams | Instacart | 112 | 20 | 14 | $4.79 | $4.69 | $3.99 | $4.13 |
| 15 | Family Dollar | Instacart | 113 | 14 | 20 | $4.99 | $2.69 | $4.99 | $3.99 |
| 16 | Whole Foods | Store site | 120 | 16 | 18 | $4.49 | $3.86 | $8.98† | $3.42 |
| 17 | Fairway | Instacart | 123 | 17 | 4 | $4.54 | $4.43 | $8.31 | $4.21 |
| 18 | H Mart | Store site | 133 | 9 | 4 | — | $6.99† | $4.50 | — |
| 19 | Gristedes | Instacart | 154 | 18 | 15 | $5.79 | $3.33 | $9.49 | $3.99 |
| 20 | D'Agostino | Instacart | 158 | 16 | 11 | $5.79 | $3.33 | $9.73 | $3.99 |
| 21 | Citarella (low confidence) | Instacart | 207 | 5 | 2 | $7.49 | — | — | $5.20 |
| 22 | 7-Eleven (low confidence) | Instacart | 216 | 7 | 42 | $7.59 | $5.99 | — | $6.49 |
| — | NYC median | — | 100 | — | — | $4.99 | $2.79 | $3.99 | $3.42 |
Source: GroceryChop price data, 134,789 prices from 368 stores at 27 chains with a five-borough ZIP code, October 6 to November 5, 2026. Each price cell is the median, across that chain's stores, of the cheapest matching product at each store. "—" means we did not capture a matching product at that chain in the window; it does not mean the store doesn't sell it. † means the value came from a single store. "Instacart" means the price is what the store's Instacart listing showed, which can run above the in-store shelf price; "Store site" prices come from the retailer's own website. Chains with fewer than 9 of the 20 staples priced are marked low-confidence. Stores sampled counts stores with prices in our data, not each chain's full NYC footprint.
The 20 staples: milk (gallon), large eggs (dozen), sandwich bread, bananas, boneless chicken breast, ground beef, white rice, dry pasta, butter, cheddar cheese, yellow onions, russet potatoes, canned black beans, peanut butter, orange juice, plain or vanilla yogurt, Gala or Fuji apples, canned tomatoes, rolled oats and granulated sugar. We excluded organic, gluten-free and multi-pack listings so every chain is priced on its everyday version. The NYC medians for the full set, for reference: milk $4.99 a gallon, eggs $2.79 a dozen, boneless chicken breast $3.99 a pound, ground beef $6.88 a pound, butter $6.84 a pound, white rice $1.01 a pound, dry pasta $1.52 a pound, bananas 69 cents a pound.
To see these prices at the stores near your own address, run a comparison for your NYC ZIP or check the New York City grocery prices page for current deals and store coverage.
How we ranked them
Most "best grocery stores in NYC" lists are written from memory, reputation or a single shopping trip. This one is built from prices.
1. A fixed set of 20 staples. These are the things almost every household buys: dairy, eggs, bread, two meats, three produce staples, rice, pasta, beans, canned tomatoes, oats, sugar, peanut butter, juice and yogurt. Specialty items, prepared food and alcohol are out.
2. The cheapest version at each store. For each staple at each store, we took the cheapest matching product, normalized to a common size: per gallon, per dozen, per pound, or per standard package. That rewards store brands, which is how a budget shopper actually buys. It also means a store-brand gallon at ALDI is compared with a store-brand gallon at Gristedes, not a premium brand.
3. The median across a chain's stores. A chain's price for a staple is the median of its per-store cheapest prices, so one unusual store doesn't decide it.
4. An index against the NYC median. For each staple we divided the chain's price by the median of all chains' prices, then took the geometric average across all staples priced at that chain. 100 is typical; lower is cheaper.
5. Honest gaps. Our data comes from what shoppers search for and what our scrapers collect, so not every chain has every staple. When a chain has fewer than 9 of the 20 staples priced, we flag it as low-confidence, and we never fill a gap with an estimate.
One limit worth knowing. Because the index uses the cheapest version we captured, a chain where we only captured premium variants of an item looks more expensive on that item than it really is. Trader Joe's is the clearest example. The only eggs we captured there in this window were pasture-raised at $5.99 a dozen, which pulls its index up. We say so in each store section where it matters.
And a second one: price source. Most NYC chains here are priced from their Instacart listings, which can run above the shelf price in the store. ALDI, Trader Joe's, Whole Foods and H Mart are priced from their own websites. That difference flatters the store-site chains slightly. It does not explain the big gaps in this table: Gristedes and D'Agostino are 54-58% above the median on Instacart, while Key Food and Food Bazaar are 16-21% below it on the same platform.
We covered the underlying approach in how grocery price comparison actually works, the pillar guide behind every ranking on this site.
Why New York grocery shopping is different
New York is not a big-box city. Inside the five boroughs most people walk or take the subway to a store within a few blocks, buy what they can carry, and shop several times a week. That shapes the market in three ways that matter for price.
Independent owners under shared banners. A large share of NYC's neighborhood supermarkets are not corporate chains at all. Key Food is "a cooperative whose members independently own and operate their stores," founded in Brooklyn in 1937, with more than 480 member supermarkets. C-Town and Bravo are banners supplied by Krasdale Foods, which serves about 250 independent supermarkets in metro New York. ShopRite stores belong to members of Wakefern, the largest retailer-owned cooperative in the US. The practical consequence: two stores with the same sign can price differently. It is one reason C-Town showed the biggest Manhattan-vs-outer-borough gap of any supermarket in our data.
Consolidation behind familiar names. Several "local" banners have changed hands recently:
- Morton Williams: Wakefern completed its purchase of the 17-store chain in October 2025. Members of the Sloan family, who established the brand, stayed on.
- Gristedes and D'Agostino: both are run by the same company, which Supermarket News described in 2022 as 19 Gristedes and 11 D'Agostino stores in Manhattan.
- Western Beef: became 100% employee-owned in April 2026. Secret NYC reported that 14 of its stores would rebrand as Food Bazaar locations by October 2026.
- Fairway: filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in January 2020. Its Manhattan stores were won at auction by Village Super Market, a ShopRite operator, for $76 million. Food Bazaar's operator was an underbidder at $75 million.
Big boxes are rare and destination-sized. NYC has a few Costcos, two Wegmans, and a growing but still small number of ALDIs and Targets. When one is reachable, it tends to rank well. Most New Yorkers' default store, though, is whatever is closest, and that is where the index gap of 50 points or more between neighbors becomes real money.
The Manhattan myth: it's the store, not the borough
We compared the same product at the same chain in Manhattan and in the outer boroughs (Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx and Staten Island). Here is every chain where we had at least 100 identical products priced on both sides:
- Trader Joe's: identical on 100% of 701 products. The Manhattan premium was 0.0%.
- Dollar Tree: identical on 100% of 146 products.
- Wegmans: 0.0% (826 products).
- Morton Williams: +0.1% (224 products).
- Gristedes: +0.6% (590 products).
- Food Bazaar: +1.1% (182 products).
- Target: +1.9% (422 products).
- C-Town: +4.6% (434 products, Manhattan higher on half of them).
- 7-Eleven: +8.7% (807 products, Manhattan higher on two-thirds).
- Whole Foods (-0.9%) and Costco (-0.4%) were marginally cheaper in Manhattan.
So the borough itself adds almost nothing at most chains. What Manhattan does have is a different store mix. All 11 D'Agostino stores and 14 of the 15 Gristedes stores in our sample are in Manhattan, and Citarella's are too. Food Bazaar, Key Food, Western Beef, Stop & Shop and ShopRite are overwhelmingly outer-borough in our data. A Manhattan shopper who switches from Gristedes to a Trader Joe's or a Target on the same avenue gets most of the "move to Queens" discount without moving.
Cheapest grocery stores by borough
We also scored each chain using only its stores in each borough, against the same citywide medians, so the numbers are on the same scale as the main table. Borough samples are smaller, and different stores stock different versions of each staple, so read these as "who came out cheapest in our data there," not a precise ranking. Only chains with at least 10 staples priced at 2 or more stores in that borough are listed.
- Brooklyn: Food Bazaar (83, 7 stores), Key Food (86), Dollar Tree (89), Western Beef (91), Stop & Shop (93) and ShopRite (94). Brooklyn had the deepest bench of below-median full-service supermarkets of any borough.
- Queens: Dollar Tree (84), Food Bazaar (84), Costco (88), Target (92) and Trader Joe's (96). H Mart's four Queens stores scored 133 on our Western-style staples, which says more about the yardstick than about H Mart.
- Manhattan: C-Town (95, 3 stores) was the only chain below 100 that met the bar. Morton Williams (114), Fairway (123), Whole Foods (137), Gristedes (154) and D'Agostino (158) followed. Trader Joe's (8 staples) and Target (8) fell just short of our cutoff in Manhattan but scored 102 and 98.
- Staten Island: ALDI (63) is the standout, and it was where most of our ALDI prices came from. Not enough other chains met the bar to rank.
- The Bronx: too thin to rank. Only Stop & Shop (105, 3 stores) met the bar.
Why Whole Foods looks pricier in Manhattan here than in Brooklyn (137 vs 109): it isn't charging more. On identical products, Whole Foods' Manhattan prices were the same as or slightly below its outer-borough prices (see the section above). The gap comes from which versions of each staple we happened to capture in each borough. It's a good reminder to compare the actual items on your list at the stores near you. Build your list and price it at your nearby stores, or check the NYC prices page for what we track in your area.
#1 — ALDI — The Cheapest Groceries in the City (When You Can Reach One)
Index: 63. The lowest in our NYC data, about 37% below the median across 13 staples.
Where it wins: ground beef at $2.99 a pound (57% below the NYC median), boneless chicken breast at $1.99 a pound (50% below), Gala apples at 66 cents a pound. Also milk at $2.71 a gallon, eggs at $1.85 a dozen and sandwich bread at $2.15. Nothing we priced at ALDI came in above the city median.
Where it loses: reach. Our five-borough sample had ALDI prices from only a handful of stores, mostly in Staten Island and Brooklyn. Its prices via Instacart (index 62, five stores including Manhattan and Queens) told the same story.
What it is: a discount grocer that is still expanding into Manhattan. Grocery Dive reported in August 2025 on a new store planned for 2026 at The Ellery, a Midtown residential building.
Who it's for: anyone with an ALDI within reach, for the weekly staples run. Pair it with a neighborhood supermarket for what ALDI doesn't carry.
#2 — Food Bazaar — The Outer-Borough Value Champion
Index: 79, across 16 staples at 15 stores. It was the cheapest full-service supermarket in our data.
Where it wins: yellow onions at 57 cents a pound (58% below the median), boneless chicken breast at $1.85 a pound (54% below, the cheapest of any chain we priced), butter at $3.50 a pound (49% below). Food Bazaar also ran the most sales of any large NYC chain: 42% of its listings carried a marked sale price in our window.
Where it loses: peanut butter ($3.00, 20% above the median). Milk is median-priced at $4.99.
What it is: Food Bazaar is operated by Bogopa Service Corp., a privately owned company that opened its first store in 1988 and is known for its international food offerings. Its own site says it prioritizes "so-called 'underserved' communities that other major supermarkets" avoid. It is growing: Secret NYC reported 14 Western Beef stores were set to become Food Bazaars by October 2026.
Who it's for: Brooklyn, Queens and Bronx households doing a full weekly shop, especially for meat and produce. The deals are frequent enough that checking the weekly deals for your ZIP before you go is worth it.
#3 — Key Food — The Cooperative Down the Block
Index: 84, across 19 of 20 staples, the broadest coverage of any discount-tier chain. We had prices from only three stores, so treat the exact number as indicative.
Where it wins: eggs at $1.58 a dozen (43% below the median), boneless chicken breast at $2.24 a pound (44% below), butter at $4.39 a pound (36% below) and milk at $3.29 a gallon.
Where it loses: rolled oats ($2.38, 26% above) and dry pasta (14% above).
What it is: a cooperative founded in Brooklyn in 1937 whose more than 480 member supermarkets are independently owned and operated. That is the most important thing to know about Key Food: your Key Food is a local owner's store, and prices, assortment and quality vary from one to the next.
Who it's for: the everyday neighborhood shop across all five boroughs. If you have two Key Foods within walking distance, they are worth comparing against each other, which is exactly what a ZIP-level price comparison does.
#4 — Dollar Tree — Cheap Pantry, No Fresh
Index: 88, across 11 staples at 30 stores, the widest store sample of any chain in this ranking.
Where it wins: sandwich bread at $1.72 (50% below the median), white rice at 65 cents a pound (35% below), dry pasta at $1.20 a pound (21% below).
Where it loses: no meat, eggs or most fresh produce in our data. Canned black beans ($1.45, 19% above) and canned tomatoes (7% above) were no bargain. Milk was $5.00 a gallon, right at the median.
Who it's for: a pantry top-up, not a weekly shop. Unit prices on small packages vary, so check the per-ounce price before assuming the dollar store wins.
#5 — Costco — Bulk Value, If You Can Carry It
Index: 89, across 12 staples at five warehouses, including the East Harlem store, which was the first tenant of East River Plaza, plus warehouses in Brooklyn, Queens and Staten Island.
Where it wins: white rice at 58 cents a pound (42% below the median), rolled oats ($1.10 per 18 oz equivalent, 41% below), yogurt (21% below) and eggs at $2.34 a dozen.
Where it loses: boneless chicken breast at $5.21 a pound (31% above the median) and bananas (20% above). Costco is priced here from its Instacart listings, which can run above warehouse prices. We also excluded multi-pack listings to keep the comparison fair, which removes some of Costco's best per-unit deals, so in the warehouse it may well be cheaper than this index suggests.
Who it's for: households with a car or a delivery habit, and the storage to use 10-pound bags. For the membership math, see Costco vs Sam's Club.
#6 — Wegmans — The Big-Box Supermarket That Prices Like a Discounter
Index: 90, across 19 staples at its two NYC stores: the Brooklyn Navy Yard store, its first in the city, opened in October 2019, and Astor Place in Manhattan, opened October 18, 2023.
Where it wins: sandwich bread at $1.63 (52% below the median, the cheapest in our data), milk at $3.29 a gallon, boneless chicken breast at $2.69 a pound and eggs at $2.43 a dozen.
Where it loses: the store-brand basics we did not capture. The only sugar we priced was a name brand that worked out to $7.87 per 4 pounds (97% above), and the oats were similar. Those are capture gaps more than real Wegmans weaknesses.
Who it's for: anyone within reach of the Navy Yard or Astor Place. Wegmans' everyday prices on the basics we did capture were among the best in New York.
#7 — Target — Competitive Staples, City-Sized Stores
Index: 91, across 17 staples at seven NYC stores we could verify as Target locations.
Where it wins: canned tomatoes ($1.14 per 28 oz equivalent, 58% below the median), eggs at $1.99 a dozen (29% below), butter at $4.99 a pound (27% below).
Where it loses: ground beef at $8.99 a pound (31% above) and yogurt (26% above). Target's NYC stores are mostly small-format, so selection is narrower than a suburban Target.
Who it's for: a solid one-stop shop on pantry and dairy if there is one on your commute. Our Target prices come from its Instacart listings; Target's own in-store price may differ.
#8 — The Fresh Grocer — One Brooklyn Store, Promising Numbers
Index: 95, from a single Brooklyn store on Fulton Street. That is too small a sample to generalize, so read this as a data point, not a verdict.
Where it wins: sandwich bread at $2.00, ground beef at $4.68 a pound (32% below), orange juice (20% below).
Where it loses: eggs at $4.69 a dozen (68% above) and yogurt (37% above).
Who it's for: downtown Brooklyn shoppers comparing it with the Key Food, Trader Joe's and Target options nearby.
#9 — Trader Joe's — Some of the City's Cheapest Pantry Staples
Index: 96, across 12 staples at 17 stores. More than any other chain, Trader Joe's index understates it.
Where it wins: butter at $2.99 a pound (56% below the median, the cheapest in the city), sandwich bread at $2.08 (39% below), dry pasta at 99 cents a pound (35% below).
Where it loses (and why the number is misleading): the only eggs we captured were pasture-raised at $5.99 a dozen, and the only yogurt was premium, so those two staples drag its index up. We didn't capture its everyday milk or chicken at all in this window.
Uniform pricing: Trader Joe's charged the same price at every NYC store we sampled. Across 701 products sold in both Manhattan and the outer boroughs, not one differed. The catch is the lines: the Upper West Side store at 72nd and Broadway has been called the busiest Trader Joe's in the world.
Who it's for: Manhattanites in particular. If your nearest supermarket is a Gristedes or D'Agostino, a Trader Joe's run for pantry staples is the single biggest saving available to you.
#10 — ShopRite — The Cooperative Supermarket for Staten Island and Beyond
Index: 96, across 17 staples at eight stores, half of them on Staten Island.
Where it wins: sandwich bread at $2.31 (32% below the median), rolled oats (28% below), canned tomatoes at $2.14 per 28 oz (20% below). ShopRite also ran frequent sales: 32% of its listings were marked down in our window.
Where it loses: eggs at $3.96 a dozen (42% above) and canned black beans (30% above).
What it is: ShopRite stores are owned by members of Wakefern Food Corp., the largest retailer-owned cooperative in the US.
Who it's for: Staten Island households doing a full weekly shop who watch the circular.
#11 — Western Beef — A Queens Chain, Now Changing Hands
Index: 103, across 16 staples at nine stores. Roughly median overall.
Where it wins: eggs at $1.53 a dozen (45% below the median, the cheapest in the city), yellow onions (35% below) and cheddar (9% below).
Where it loses: orange juice at $6.29 per 52 oz (37% above) and apples (61% above).
What it is: a Queens-based chain whose first store opened in Flushing in 1980. It became fully employee-owned in April 2026, and 14 of its stores were reported to be converting to Food Bazaar. Some of the "Western Beef" stores in our October data may have changed banner during the window.
Who it's for: shoppers near a remaining location, especially for eggs. Check which banner your store is flying now.
#12 — Stop & Shop — Mid-Pack, Outer-Borough Supermarket
Index: 106, across 18 staples at 13 stores in the Bronx, Brooklyn, Queens and Staten Island.
Where it wins: canned tomatoes at $2.09 per 28 oz (22% below the median), canned black beans (15% below), eggs at $2.39 a dozen (14% below).
Where it loses: bananas at $1.29 a pound (87% above) and dry pasta (57% above). Stop & Shop is owned by Ahold Delhaize.
Who it's for: outer-borough shoppers who want a conventional supermarket. Only about 8% of its listings were on sale in our window, so its shelf price is mostly what you pay.
#13 — C-Town — The Independent Owners' Banner
Index: 107, across 16 staples at 10 stores in every borough.
Where it wins: russet potatoes at 56 cents a pound (37% below the median), white rice at 68 cents a pound (32% below), eggs at $2.19 a dozen (22% below).
Where it loses: boneless chicken breast at $8.79 a pound (from one store, a premium brand) and dry pasta at $2.79 a pound (84% above).
What it is: C-Town stores are independently owned and supplied by Krasdale Foods, which also supplies Bravo. That independence shows in the data. C-Town had the largest Manhattan premium of any supermarket we measured: 4.6% on identical products, with Manhattan higher on half of them. Two C-Towns can be very different stores.
Who it's for: neighborhood shoppers. Compare your C-Town with the other stores on your block before assuming it's the cheap option.
#14 — Morton Williams — Manhattan's Mid-Priced Neighborhood Supermarket
Index: 112, across all 20 staples at 14 stores. It was the only chain where we priced the full set.
Where it wins: bananas at 34 cents a pound (51% below the median, the cheapest in the city), ground beef at $4.62 a pound (33% below), rolled oats (25% below).
Where it loses: white rice at $2.00 a pound (98% above) and sugar (115% above).
What it is: a Manhattan chain established by the Sloan family, acquired by Wakefern in October 2025 with 17 stores in Manhattan, the Bronx and Jersey City.
Who it's for: Manhattan residents who need a full-service supermarket nearby. It's meaningfully cheaper than Gristedes or D'Agostino (index 154-158) and about 12% above the city median.
#15 — Family Dollar — Convenient, But Not Cheap
Index: 113, across 14 staples at 20 stores.
Where it wins: canned tomatoes (22% below the median). Peanut butter and eggs were near the median.
Where it loses: canned black beans (47% above) and rolled oats at $3.99 per 18 oz equivalent (111% above).
Who it's for: emergency top-ups. Unlike Dollar Tree, Family Dollar did not beat the median on most staples we priced.
#16 — Whole Foods — Cheap Pantry, Expensive Meat
Index: 120, across 16 staples at 18 stores, 14 of them in Manhattan.
Where it wins: 365-brand peanut butter at $1.92 per 16 oz (23% below the median), dry pasta at $1.29 a pound (15% below), orange juice (12% below). Milk at $4.49 a gallon is also below the median.
Where it loses: boneless chicken breast at $8.98 a pound (125% above; the cheapest we found was an air-chilled 8-oz pack) and rolled oats (181% above; the only oats we captured were sprouted).
Who it's for: Whole Foods' 365 pantry line competes with the discounters. Its fresh meat and specialty items don't. Use it for pantry staples if it's your closest store, and buy meat elsewhere.
#17 — Fairway — A Famous Name, Now Under ShopRite's Operator
Index: 123, across 17 staples at four Manhattan stores.
Where it wins: canned black beans (10% below the median), milk at $4.54 a gallon (9% below), peanut butter (8% below).
Where it loses: boneless chicken breast at $8.31 a pound (108% above) and dry pasta at $2.71 a pound (79% above).
What it is: Fairway filed for Chapter 11 in January 2020. Its Upper West Side flagship and its Upper East Side, Kips Bay and Chelsea stores went to Village Super Market, which operates ShopRite stores.
Who it's for: Upper West Side and Upper East Side shoppers who want specialty assortment. On staples it's above average.
#18 — H Mart — Rank It on What It's For
Index: 133, but across only 9 staples at four Queens stores. That is the lowest coverage of any chain we ranked with confidence, and the wrong yardstick for H Mart.
Where it wins: white rice at 73 cents a pound (27% below the median) and yogurt (8% below).
Where it loses on our list: eggs at $6.99 a dozen (one store) and cheddar (129% above). Those are not what people go to H Mart for.
What it is: H Mart started in 1982 with a single store in Woodside, Queens and has grown to more than 97 stores across the US, calling itself the largest Asian supermarket chain in America. The Queens stores in our data include Flushing and Bayside.
Who it's for: shoppers cooking with Asian ingredients, which is what H Mart stocks and what our 20 Western-style staples don't measure. Its white rice was among the cheapest in the city. For cheddar and eggs, shop elsewhere.
#19 — Gristedes — Manhattan's Most Expensive Supermarket Chain
Index: 154, across 18 staples at 15 stores, 14 of them in Manhattan.
Where it wins: nothing we priced was below the NYC median. Its closest-to-median staples were russet potatoes ($1.00 a pound, 12% above), apples (15% above) and milk at $5.79 a gallon (16% above).
Where it loses: boneless chicken breast at $9.49 a pound (138% above) and canned black beans at $2.60 (114% above).
What it is: Gristedes and D'Agostino are run by the same company. In 2022 it operated 19 Gristedes and 11 D'Agostino stores in Manhattan.
Who it's for: convenience in Manhattan neighborhoods where it's the only supermarket within a few blocks. For a full weekly shop, almost any other store on this list saves money.
#20 — D'Agostino — Gristedes' Sister, Priced the Same
Index: 158, across 16 staples at 11 Manhattan stores.
Where it wins: like Gristedes, nothing below the median. Russet potatoes, milk ($5.79) and sandwich bread ($3.99) were its closest.
Where it loses: boneless chicken breast at $9.73 a pound (144% above) and canned black beans at $2.60 (114% above).
The twin finding: D'Agostino and Gristedes priced milk ($5.79), eggs ($3.33), sandwich bread ($3.99), black beans ($2.60) and russets ($1.00) identically in our data, consistent with shared ownership and buying.
Who it's for: the same as Gristedes. If both are near you, they aren't really competing with each other.
#21 — Citarella — Gourmet Market (Low Confidence)
Index: 207, but on only 5 staples at two stores. That's not enough to rank it with confidence.
What we saw: milk at $7.49 a gallon (50% above the median), sandwich bread at $5.20, and canned tomatoes and rice far above the median.
Who it's for: not staples shoppers. On the few everyday items we could price, it was the most expensive supermarket in the city. We couldn't fetch Citarella's own history page, so we're not repeating claims about the business.
#22 — 7-Eleven — The Convenience Tax (Low Confidence)
Index: 216, on 7 staples at 42 stores. The coverage is thin, but the direction is not in doubt.
What we saw: milk at $7.59 a gallon (52% above the median), sandwich bread at $6.49 (90% above), eggs at $5.99 a dozen, white rice at $3.59 a pound (257% above). 7-Eleven also had the largest Manhattan premium of any chain: 8.7% on identical products.
Who it's for: milk at 11pm. For anything you can plan, it costs about double.
Don't skip these New York institutions
Some of the most important places to buy food in New York aren't chains we can index on staples. Two worth knowing:
Kalustyan's (Lexington Avenue, Midtown). A specialty food market that has stood on Lexington Avenue since 1944, founded by Turkish-Armenian immigrant Kerope Kalustyan. CBS New York describes professional chefs and home cooks going there for hard-to-find flavors from faraway places; its co-owner calls it "an institution." It isn't in our price data, so we can't say how it compares on price.
The independent co-op and banner stores. Key Food, C-Town, Bravo and Associated stores are largely independently owned. Associated Supermarket Group describes each of its Associated, Compare Foods, Met Foodmarkets and Pioneer banners as "independently owned and operated." The best one on your block may beat a bigger-name store, and the worst may not. That is the strongest argument for comparing your actual nearby stores rather than trusting a chain's reputation.
The smart NYC shopping strategy
1. Find your two closest stores in the top half of the table. For most New Yorkers that means a Key Food, Food Bazaar, C-Town, Target or Trader Joe's within walking distance, plus a Costco, Wegmans or ALDI reachable occasionally.
2. Split pantry from fresh. Trader Joe's and Whole Foods' 365 line are cheap on pantry (butter, pasta, peanut butter, bread) even though their overall indexes are middling. Buy pantry there if it's convenient. Buy meat at Food Bazaar, Key Food, Wegmans or ALDI, where boneless chicken breast ran $1.85-$2.69 a pound against $8-$10 at Whole Foods, Fairway, Gristedes and D'Agostino.
3. In Manhattan, change stores, not boroughs. Same-chain prices barely move across the river. Moving your weekly shop from a Gristedes or D'Agostino (index 154-158) to a Trader Joe's, Target or Morton Williams (96-112) saves far more than any borough effect.
4. Use the deals at the deal-heavy chains. Food Bazaar (42% of listings on sale in our window), ShopRite (32%), H Mart (31%) and Fairway (21%) run frequent markdowns. Trader Joe's and ALDI essentially don't; their shelf price is the price. Check the deals near your ZIP before a Food Bazaar or ShopRite trip.
5. Avoid the convenience tax on anything you can plan. 7-Eleven milk at $7.59 a gallon versus $3.29 at Key Food or Wegmans is a $4.30 difference on a single item.
How to use GroceryChop in New York City
- Compare prices by ZIP. Search an item with your ZIP and see prices from the NYC stores near you, sorted cheapest first, with unit prices shown where available.
- Build your weekly list and price the whole thing at nearby stores to see which single store is cheapest for your actual basket, with a store-by-store breakdown. Swap or lock any match you disagree with.
- See NYC grocery prices and deals for the city as a whole, including the stores we track most often.
- Ask ChopBot something like "where's the cheapest chicken breast near 11372" and it will compare nearby stores from our price data. It can't place orders or guarantee in-store prices.
Frequently asked questions
What is the cheapest grocery store in NYC?
ALDI was the cheapest grocery store in our New York City price data, with an index of 63, meaning its staples cost about 37% less than the NYC median. Food Bazaar (79) and Key Food (84) were the cheapest full-service supermarkets. We priced 20 staples at 368 stores across the five boroughs between October 6 and November 5, 2026.
What is the most expensive grocery store in NYC?
Among supermarkets, Gristedes (index 154) and D'Agostino (158) were the most expensive in our data, roughly 54-58% above the NYC median on the same staples. Citarella (207) and 7-Eleven (216) were higher still, but we could only price 5 to 7 of our 20 staples at each, so treat those two as low-confidence.
Is Manhattan more expensive than Brooklyn and Queens for groceries?
Mostly because of which stores are there, not because chains charge more. When we compared the same product at the same chain, Manhattan prices were within about 2% of outer-borough prices for most chains, and identical at Trader Joe's. C-Town (+4.6%) and 7-Eleven (+8.7%) were the exceptions. Manhattan's bills run high because Gristedes, D'Agostino and Citarella are concentrated there.
Is Trader Joe's cheap in NYC?
Trader Joe's is cheap on some staples and middling overall. In our data its butter ($2.99 a pound), sandwich bread ($2.08) and dry pasta (99 cents a pound) were among the cheapest in the city, and its prices were identical across every NYC store we sampled. Its index of 96 is pulled up by the items we captured there being pasture-raised eggs and premium yogurt.
Is Whole Foods expensive in NYC?
Whole Foods scored 120 in our NYC index, about 20% above the median. It was actually competitive on pantry staples (365-brand peanut butter at $1.92, pasta at $1.29 a pound, orange juice) and expensive on fresh meat: its cheapest boneless chicken breast we found worked out to $8.98 a pound, against a NYC median of $3.99.
Who owns Key Food, C-Town and Food Bazaar?
None of them is a single corporate chain. Key Food is a cooperative founded in Brooklyn in 1937 whose members independently own and run their stores. C-Town and Bravo are banners supplied by Krasdale Foods to independent owners. Food Bazaar is operated by the privately owned Bogopa Service Corp., which first opened in 1988.
How did you rank the NYC grocery stores?
We took 20 everyday staples (milk, eggs, bread, chicken, rice, pasta, butter and more), found each store's cheapest version of each one, and compared it with the NYC median for that staple. A chain's index is the average of those ratios, so 100 is a typical NYC price and 80 means about 20% cheaper. Chains with fewer than 9 staples priced are marked low-confidence.
The takeaway
New York's grocery prices are less about the borough than the sign over the door. Across 368 stores, the same staples cost about 37% less than the city median at ALDI, 16-21% less at Food Bazaar and Key Food, and 54-58% more at Gristedes and D'Agostino, while a given chain charged Manhattan almost exactly what it charged Queens. The cheapest move most New Yorkers can make is not a trip to a far-off warehouse; it's switching the weekly shop to the cheaper of the two or three stores already within walking distance, and buying pantry staples where they're cheap.
The same approach drives our other metro rankings: Chicago, Los Angeles, San Francisco and San Diego, plus our national list of the cheapest grocery stores in America.
Ready to start saving on groceries?
Compare real-time prices across 100+ stores, find the cheapest options near you, and build a smart shopping list — all free.
Get GroceryChop updates by email
Grocery savings tips and product news, when we have them. No spam.
Keep reading
Is Vons or Ralphs Cheaper? Vons vs Ralphs vs Albertsons, Priced at 346 SoCal Stores (2026)
We priced 17 staples at Vons, Ralphs and Albertsons across Southern California. Ralphs was cheaper: $40.32 vs $52.05 at Vons and $53.98 at Albertsons. Vons and Albertsons run far more deals, and without those deals the gap widens.
GuidesAI Grocery List (2026): What ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude Get Wrong, and How to Price Yours
An AI grocery list is fast to make, but the AI cannot see what it costs. We priced one 10-item list at 17 San Diego chains: $23.25 at the cheapest store, $47.51 at the priciest.